How to Approve a Pull Request in GitHub?

Pull Requests (PRs) are a core feature of GitHub that facilitates collaboration in software development. They allow developers to propose, review, and merge changes into a codebase. Approving a pull request is a critical step in the review process, signifying that the code has been reviewed and is ready to be merged.

In this blog, we’ll guide you through the process of approving a pull request on GitHub and share some best practices for an effective review.

What Does Approving a Pull Request Mean?

Approving a pull request indicates that you have reviewed the proposed changes, verified that they meet the project’s standards, and are satisfied that they can be merged into the base branch.

Key Actions in a PR Approval:

1. Code Review: Examine the proposed changes for correctness, readability, and adherence to project guidelines.
2. Testing: Run tests (if applicable) to ensure functionality remains intact.
3. Approval: Approve the pull request if it meets all requirements.

---

Prerequisites for Approving a Pull Request

1. Access Permissions:
   • You must be a collaborator, team member, or have appropriate permissions to approve a PR.
2. Review Process Configured:
   • Ensure the repository has been configured to require reviews before merging, if necessary.

---

Step-by-Step Guide to Approving a Pull Request on GitHub

Step 1: Navigate to the Pull Request

1. Log in to your GitHub account.
2. Go to the repository containing the pull request.
3. Click on the Pull Requests tab at the top of the repository page.
4. Select the pull request you wish to review from the list.

---

Step 2: Review the Pull Request

1. View Changes:
   • Click the Files changed tab to review the code changes.
   • Use GitHub’s inline commenting feature to leave feedback on specific lines of code, if needed.
2. Check Commit History:
   • Navigate to the Commits tab to review the commit messages and ensure they are meaningful and relevant.
3. Run Tests (if applicable):
   • Clone the branch locally and run tests to validate the changes: git checkout <branch-name> git pull origin <branch-name>

---

Step 3: Provide Feedback

1. If changes are required:
   • Leave comments or request changes directly in the Files changed view.
   • Click Request changes to indicate that the pull request needs revisions before approval.
2. If the changes are satisfactory:
   • Skip to the next step.

---

Step 4: Approve the Pull Request

1. Click the Review changes button located at the top-right corner of the pull request page.
2. Select the Approve option.
3. (Optional) Add a comment to document your approval or any notes for the team.
4. Click Submit review to finalize your approval.

---

Step 5: Merge the Pull Request (Optional)

If you have merge permissions and the pull request has been approved:

1. Select the appropriate merge option:
   • Merge Commit: Combines all commits from the branch into the base branch.
   • Squash and Merge: Combines all commits into a single commit before merging.
   • Rebase and Merge: Reapplies commits on top of the base branch.
2. Click Confirm merge to complete the process.

---

Best Practices for Approving a Pull Request

1. Thorough Review:
   • Always review the code thoroughly for correctness, performance, and security.
2. Adhere to Coding Standards:
   • Check that the code follows the project’s style guide and best practices.
3. Communicate Clearly:
   • Provide constructive feedback and document your approval with comments.
4. Ensure Tests Pass:
   • Verify that all tests pass, and no new issues are introduced.
5. Avoid Rushed Approvals:
   • Take your time to ensure the pull request meets all quality standards before approving.

---

Troubleshooting Common Issues

1. Can’t Approve the Pull Request

• Ensure you have the appropriate permissions in the repository.
• Confirm that the pull request is open and not already merged or closed.

2. Conflicts in the Pull Request

• If there are merge conflicts, work with the contributor to resolve them before approving.

3. Failing Tests

• Request changes and ask the contributor to fix the tests before approval.

---

Conclusion

Approving a pull request is a vital step in maintaining code quality and fostering collaboration in a team. By following the steps outlined in this guide and adhering to best practices, you can ensure that the review process is thorough and efficient.

Remember, a well-reviewed pull request not only improves the codebase but also enhances teamwork and trust among collaborators.